Thinking of starting fresh on a new island, but I also love my current one. Help.

Restarting would have the same results, wouldn’t it?

So why not just create a new profile then?

Sadly you can only have one island per console, so creating a new profile wouldn’t allow me to have a new island.

It depends my old island was super messy and I never got around to cleaning it up honestly I don't regret it at all because now on this forum I can have visitors and they won't take my stuff

Plus you don't have to completely flatten it flatten parts you want gone and start a new theme you can also keep your progress and villagers